Why teaching music reading is the wrong way to teach piano [Part 1]

By Paul Myatt | Aural

Jul 11

music reading

In this article, Inner Circle Expert teacher Paul Myatt will get you thinking about the order in which you are teaching music. What should come first: reading or listening/creating/singing? 

As you might have guessed, there is a wealth of evidence to suggest that the best way to teach music is the same as the way we learn to speak language: listening first.

But how does that apply to piano teaching and what does it look like in practice? That’s exactly what Paul dives into in this article. 

In fact, we’ve got so much to explore on this topic, that I’ve decided to break it into two articles. In Part 1, Paul uncovers the “Natural Learning Process” that should guide the way in which we teach music and we begin to explore multi-sensory learning. 

I know you’re going to love this so let’s get started. – Tim Topham.

Ear or Eye?

The battle-lines are surely drawn.

In the blue corner we have the readers and in the red, the by ear-ers. Of course we all know that to be a successful all-round musician (piano player), you need both….but how many of us teach both?

Regularly? Competently?

Join any Facebook group about teaching piano and you’ll regularly see a post devoted to ensuring children are reading and sometimes about children learning to play by ear, very occasionally about a child improvising or, shock horror, “making it up” (isn’t that called composing 😉 usually from a more progressive teacher, devoted to their craft.

In my experience, most teachers teach how they were taught, (funnily enough, the experts say the same thing).

Unfortunately in our profession, there are few opportunities to learn “how to” teach. Most tertiary courses offer limited pedagogy courses specifically designed for piano or instrumentalists. Add the lack of any regulation within the industry, creating low participation in professional development either musically or in business.

I imagine if you’re reading this, you probably are already engaged in your own professional development and that is a great thing, so keep reading!

What do the experts say?

Have you read the 2015 Keynote Address by Dr Edward E. Gordon at the National Conference on Keyboard Pedagogy held in the US?

Highly recommended reading.

Dr Gordon said,

“I am lead to believe piano is taught to many persons by teachers who typically teach the way they were taught, rather than according to an objective learning theory and current research”.

He goes on to say that he has no intention in being critical, however he wanted to share concepts that may encourage teachers to embrace new concepts in their own pedagogy.

Dr Gordon said using language as an analogy should make it easier to grasp what he explains about music instruction and in particular piano instruction.

He said, there are 5 language skill vocabularies: listening, speaking, thinking, reading and writing, each providing readiness for the next step.

Gordon emphasises that listening comes first and is fundamental, “Without a rich listening vocabulary, development of a speaking vocabulary with proper pronunciation is restricted.”

Natural Learning Process-HR2

Gordon goes on to say,

“There are five parallel music skill vocabularies. In sequential order of development, they are 1) listening, 2) singing and chanting, 3) audiating and improvising, 4) reading, and 5) writing. As with language, listening is basic in piano instruction as well as all music instruction. Unfortunately, in typical instruction, listening is disregarded. Detrimental results are similar in music as in language when importance of listening is overlooked.”

Natural Learning Process-HR

The importance of listening

Without incorporating listening and singing and/or chanting, the context of tonality is often lost.

How does one experience major and minor tonalities let alone modal tonalities without listening and/or singing? And then, what about meter? Should this not be experienced in the body? Gordon says, “It is indeed regrettable most students throughout the world display poor rhythm.”

So if you’re a good reader, you probably focus on this in your teaching.

If you enjoy playing by ear, you will generally teach your students to do that as well. Let’s face it, just like our students, we always like to do things that we’re good at!

Teaching piano by ear

Here’s the first challenge: encourage readers to play by ear, and play by ear-ers to read.

To start with I want to define teaching by ear and teaching by reading.

  • Teaching by ear is when children listen to the piece, then play the song from what they have heard.
  • Teaching by reading happens when students have the music in front of them, they decode it and commence playing.

Let’s look at the options for learning music by reading.

Firstly one should look at the age of the student. If a child starts learning piano at the age for 5 or 6 years, then they are often too young read their own language fluently, therefore it is unlikely that they will be able to read the music, decipher it and then play it.

The variation in students’ ability to decode information from music in beginners, ages 7-11 years, is enormous.

An understanding of music notation and how it is deciphered and decoded by the brain, is important to start this conversation.

Music notation written on a stave is a vertical (up-down) representation of pitch and the piano is a horizontal (left-right) representation of pitch.

The next layer of complexity is the layout of notes on a piano.

Notes are not found by using the white keys, they are found by their relationship to the black notes. Keyboard geography is important to understand; and this explains why many courses begin with playing 2 or 3 black notes prior to playing white notes.

When a child does not have a strong background in two & three black note exploration, he or she will often mistake F for C and vice versa.

piano-keyboard-black-white

Vertical versus Horizontal

A student’s spatial awareness is essential for deciphering musical notation: turning the information around in one’s brain and then expressing that notation through the fingers playing notes on the piano.

In my dim dark past I have taught adults who were unable to decode music notation until I turned the music on its side, so that the printed score went in the same direction as the notes on the piano.

As piano teachers, we often don’t realise that our own basic assumptions around reading music are unfathomable for some people.

What is Multi-sensory Learning?

As playing music is a multi-sensory experience, ie we need to play, read & listen, I believe we, as piano teachers, we should teach using a multi-sensory approach.

Singing, clapping/moving and following the printed score along with a recording or the teacher playing will give students a multi-sensory experience of the music before actually playing.

Singing lyrics or note names (C, D, E or solfa/solfege) gives students an auditory experience. Clapping, moving or playing a percussion instrument gives students a kinaesthetic experience and following the notes on the printed music offers a visual experience of the music.

These multi-sensory experiences engage many different areas of the brain. Check out Anita Collin’s TEDx talk and Tim’s great podcast with Anita: What to say to parents when their child is about to quit.

I often relate multi-sensory learning and what happens in the brain to bush walking.

If you’re bush walking through virgin forests you’ve got to work hard to make tracks, where as, a well-worn track is easier to navigate.

Multi-sensory learning is like making well-worn pathways in the brain. Stronger conduits in the brain create improved memory (mechanical, auditory & analytical) and enhance learning.

multi sensory piano teaching

Multi-sensory learning is much of the approach of the Orff-Schulwerk and Dalcroze philosophies.

Whilst neither is necessarily piano related, many of the strategies of the approaches can be related to, and incorporated into piano lessons.

Multi-sensory learning is also favoured for learning many subjects in school curriculums as well. See Tim’s Podcasts with Paula Melville-Clark and Vashti Summervill.

Incorporating multi-sensory learning into your lessons takes preparation and commitment to your own teaching pedagogy. There are many benefits to the students, generally they will:

  • play more “musically” – i.e. have a better “feel” for the music
  • often are able to “play by ear” as well as read
  • memorise easily – mechanical, auditory & analytical memory
  • will read if they are having fun
  • enjoy improvising and composing

Conclusion

In Part 2 of the series, I’ll let you know about some of the strategies that I use that can help make your teaching more multi-sensory.

We’ll discuss Aural Strategies, Reading Strategies and the Importance of Singing.

We’ll also cover some of the best resources for supporting your teaching including links to online resources, teaching frameworks and communities.

What order do you teach?

Do you start with reading? How do you help students listen and learn the fundamentals of rhythm?

How do you start your beginners? What does your first month of lessons look like?

Follow

About the Author

Paul Myatt is a Director of Forte School of Music and a passionate piano teacher. He believes strongly in professional development for piano teachers and regularly participates in conferences and workshops to improve his skill. Paul along with Gillian Erksine has written and created the teaching materials which are incorporated into Forte's education system which has over 4,000 students. Together they also write easiLEARN® Fundamentals Theory and Piano (available through all good music shops and Hal Leonard Australia, previous published by Warner Bros & Alfred Pub) which have been best sellers with many piano teachers. The AMEB has included their arrangements in examination books. As a performer, Paul sings Bass in the Sydney Symphony Chorus and plays piano in a Cabaret show called 2Pauls. As part of his own professional improvement he is currently studying his A.Mus.A in Classical Singing. Paul has his own blog at www.paulmyatt.com.au

(9) comments

Add Your Reply
×
Enjoy this video? Sign up for updates.
Click below to get notified next time I go live.